Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 10 oz plastic bag with designed header card
- Style number: 54040-CHEY
Chocolatey Eyeballs recalled for undeclared milk.
Five packages of Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs were recalled because their labels do not declare milk. People with a milk allergy or severe sensitivity could have a serious or life-threatening reaction. No illnesses were reported when announced.
AnnouncedAug 31, 2026
DistributedAZ, TX, VA, GA, MA, NC, IN, NV, CA, NJ, CT, OH, WY
RetailersMarshalls, TJ Maxx, HomeGoods, Sierra
First, a reality check.
Opening this guide has not checked your food. Compare your package details with the reviewed notice. A barcode or product photo alone may not answer every recall question.
What happened
Undeclared milk allergen.
No illnesses reported when announced; this may change
What to check
- package code
Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 7 oz acrylic box with designed paper wrap
- Style number: 54077-CHEY
Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 10.5 oz round plastic jar
- Style number: 58008-CHEY
Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 16 oz designer plastic pouch
- Style number: 58089-CHEY
Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 11 oz plastic bag tied with a tag
- Style number: 54083-CHEY
What to do now
Do not consume an affected package. FDA says to destroy the product. For a refund, contact Crystal Temptations with proof of purchase; stores are not issuing refunds.
Check my package →If a required number is missing or unreadable, do not treat that as a no-match. Check the official notice or ask the retailer.