Official recall imageChocolatey Eyeballs recalled for undeclared milk
Five packages of Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs were recalled because their labels do not declare milk. People with a milk allergy or severe sensitivity could have a serious or life-threatening reaction. No illnesses were reported when announced.
Source: FDA official record ↗- Where
- AZ, TX, VA, GA, MA, NC, IN, NV, CA, NJ, CT, OH, WY
- Announced
- Aug 31, 2026
- Product
- Chocolatey Eyeballs · Crystal Temptations / Little Temptations
- Last updated
- Aug 31, 2026
- Distribution
- AZ, TX, VA, GA, MA, NC, IN, NV, CA, NJ, CT, OH, WY
- Retailers
- NAMED RETAILERMarshallsNAMED RETAILERTJ MaxxNAMED RETAILERHomeGoodsNAMED RETAILERSierra
About the official classification
An official classification has not been verified for this record. That does not mean it is low risk or your package is unaffected.
Check Halloween Chocolatey Eyeballs for an undeclared milk allergen.
- Five package styles were recalled after whey (milk) was found in products whose labels did not declare milk.
- The announcement reported no illnesses.
- Package styles
- 5
- States
- 13
- Reported illnesses
- 0
- Classification
- Pending
The notice names Marshalls, TJ Maxx, HomeGoods and Sierra stores in 13 states.
All affected products and identifiers
Check the package—not just the product name.
Match the style number and package size shown on the label. This is especially urgent for anyone with a milk allergy or severe sensitivity.
Chocolatey Eyeballs1 identifiers
Match every identifier marked as required for this product.
- Style number:
54040-CHEY
Chocolatey Eyeballs1 identifiers
Match every identifier marked as required for this product.
- Style number:
54077-CHEY
Chocolatey Eyeballs1 identifiers
Match every identifier marked as required for this product.
- Style number:
58008-CHEY
Chocolatey Eyeballs1 identifiers
Match every identifier marked as required for this product.
- Style number:
58089-CHEY
Chocolatey Eyeballs1 identifiers
Match every identifier marked as required for this product.
- Style number:
54083-CHEY
Products in this reviewed record.
Photos help locate the label; only identifiers confirm a match.
Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 10 oz plastic bag with designed header card
Check this package →
Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 7 oz acrylic box with designed paper wrap
Check this package →
Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 10.5 oz round plastic jar
Check this package →
Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 16 oz designer plastic pouch
Check this package →
Chocolatey Eyeballs
Crystal Temptations · 11 oz plastic bag tied with a tag
Check this package →Follow the reviewed instructions.
Do not consume an affected package. FDA says to destroy the product. For a refund, contact Crystal Temptations with proof of purchase; stores are not issuing refunds.
Save this recall guide Email or PDF
Your guide, in your inbox.
A quick, phone-friendly guide to the affected products, package details and next steps. Download a polished PDF if you want to keep or share it.